Recently I heard that the Hokkaido Speech competition disqualified a prospective contestant (a junior high school student) simply because one of the student's parents was originally from the Philippines. Thus arises the discussion:
Having lived here as a foreigner, it would be a lie to say that there is not a lot of "racism" in Japan. In fact, if we were living by US politically correct standards, most of the people I know would be racists. But I don't mean this in a derogatory way. The Japanese culture has far less diversity than that of the US. And although the "foreigner" population has been steadily increasing recently, most Japanese consider Japan to be a homogeneous population. "We are Japanese people, anyone else is gaikokujin." (Foreigner, literally: outsider, outside country person.) So anyone who doesn't look "Japanese" is a foreigner, no matter what length of time they have lived in the country. Again, this is a cultural difference, I want to point out that this is not a country of Hitlers and they don't hate all foreigners and sit at home and burn voodoo dolls of us. But, they are often very underexposed to the idea of racism or diversity in a culture. Par example:
In one of my elementary schools there is a child who has a parent from Sweden. And, thus, he has blond hair and looks like a stereotypical European kid. The thing is that he has lived in Japan his entire life. He can only speak Japanese. He is a Japanese person in as much as I am an American. (for those of you who don't know, my mother is originally from Sri Lanka) But! In his class all of the students talk about him as the Swedish person. When I came to teach them they said, "We've got a Swedish person in our class, go talk English to him!!" "Oh, he's Swedish, talk to him!" "Oh,
is gaikokujin like you!" And various chants of the sort. I was appalled. I mean, these were not teasing or bullying. If anything he was like a celebrity because he was their very own foreigner. But, that was it. This was completely normal. No one even considered it strange. It was just fact. To the students and even the teachers. He is a foreigner, we are Japanese. He's cooler because he is a foreigner and lets make him talk to the other foreigner. And the funny thing is that when they dragged me over to him and made him talk to me, he couldn't speak a word of English. As expected from a normal Japanese elementary school student. In fact, one of the fully Japanese girls spoke much better than him.
It's kind of sad. If you look at it from a Japanese viewpoint, it is just kids and not meant in any aggressive or demeaning way. But this kid will live his whole life like this, on the outside.
Do you know how I am introduced in class? As a "half". If is actually the same in Japanese: "haafu". And here in Japan that is not a derogatory term. So I don't begrudge them, but I do flinch a little every time I hear it. That kid was later explained to be as being a half. And anytime I explain my background, they say things like, "Oh, you're not a real American, you're a half." This is said with perfectly straight faces by perfectly friendly and well meaning people. So I ignore the word half, but explain that in America we have a lot of cultural diversity and that I am, in fact, an American.
Needless to say, any of those ultra sensitive about their race or profiling based on skin color or appearance should avoid the land of the rising sun if they don't want to spoil their day. Or maybe they should visit. It might help to show how much advancements have been made in your respective country, although no country has it perfect yet as far as I know.
Anyway, back to the story of the Speech contest. There may be some actual validity in the reasoning behind this banning of "halfs". That being, that if they have an English speaking parent and they speak both languages, then they will have a huge advantage in the contest. But, of course, there is no way to measure that. The kid at my elementary would have been disqualified, and he was no better than any other Japanese kid. But again, they can't exactly go to every house and check, so they is a tricky question... How do you make it fair? I keep trying to think what we would do in the US. Say a Spanish speaking contest. I kind of think that the contest would not ban anyone as long as their first language was English. Or maybe as long as they could not claim Spanish as a spoken language. This would be somewhat based on person to person honesty, although your teacher has to sign you up. And in the end there would happen to be some people who were basically fluent and the rest of us might feel like it was a little unfair. But, still... I can't help feeling that what is happening here is not quite the best way to handle it. I mean, we will be excluding students simply based on race. And basically it's based on their parents' race. So... Well, what do you think? Post a reply on my blog. Let me know.
I just want to point out that I love Japan and I'm enjoying my stay greatly. The people are great and friendly. My intention is not to badmouth Japan, it is simply to ask questions and spread awareness about Japanese culture. No culture, no country is perfect. My country has tons of problems of it's own. But I live here now, so I'm focusing on these problems. Happy Blogging! :)